MORE Indie Invaders / POSTED BY: KINGSOFAR

I had an artist manager ask me a new one yesterday: How do I get live performance footage of new songs recorded on someone’s cell phone removed from YouTube? This isn’t really a new request, we have to have material taken down from websites fairly often. What is new about it is that the recording was made on a handheld digital recorder by a fan at a show where the artist was trying out new material.  Â

Until YouTube, it was possible to “open in Philadelphiaâ€? to try out new material, a time-honored tradition in our business. Artists frequently try out material in small clubs in small towns, and may completely rewrite songs based on how they “feelâ€? live or simply not use certain songs. (This is obviously not limited to artists, but also would include comedians, broadway shows, any number of performers.) Â

My artist client now has to pay me to write notice and takedown letters to YouTube to exercise rights under the DMCA—the same week that YouTube is rumored to be fetching an asking price over $1 billion dollars. That’s billion with a B. My artist asked me to explain to him how it is that YouTube is able to make more money from infringing his work than any artist will ever see in their lifetimes, yet he has to take the time to send a cease and desist to YouTube in some kind of grotesque game cyber shakedown. Â

Of course it is true that anyone can record an artist’s performance anywhere, that’s not the problem. The problem is not with the fan, and I refuse to allow YouTube to try to make it so.

The problem is that YouTube makes no apparent effort to filter videos that are of obviously questionable origin. Riddle me this: If an artist wanted to make their video available on YouTube, would they typically want to post a poor quality video, or would they more likely be interested in keeping that kind of video off of YouTube.

The lawyers for YouTube have tried to get around this issue by implying that they have no way of knowing whether a video that is uploaded is secretly being uploaded by the artist themselves to start a grass roots campaign. The same is true of movie studios or record companies.

There’s a very easy fix to that problem: Ask them. Ask the artist’s permission before YouTube permits the video to be posted. But of course YouTube can’t do that. Asking permission doesn’t “scaleâ€?.   Â

What YouTube means when they say that something doesn’t scale is that in order to accomplish a particular thing, they would have to spend money they don’t have on resources they don’t want to achieve a goal for which they have contempt. It’s like saying, yes I know I may be stealing from you, but it’s too inconvenient for me to find out. Sounds infantile when you think of it that way right?

If a child said that to their parents, they would likely be grounded for a good long time. It’s time to ground YouTube.

Chris Castle is a music attorney in Los Angeles where he represents artists (including KOAR fav 10 Years), producers, music industry executives, songwriters, independent publishers and record companies, and technology companies. Chris is a contributing editor to Entertainment Law & Finance and writes the Music-Tech-Policy blog (http://music-tech-policy.blogspot.com/). He is on the board of directors of the Austin Music Foundation and moderates the digital panel at SXSW. Before law school, he was the drummer for Jesse Winchester, Long John Baldry and Yvonne Elliman
Â

Twitter
Facebook
Newsletter
Recent Posts
  • Lauren Spring Shares Self Soother About Healing After Toxic Love
  • Abbie Anne Breaks Through Self-Doubt with Honest New Track Miss Mediocre
  • Alyssa Caroline Releases Lovesick About Moving On After Betrayal
  • Savannah Burrows Shares Dreamy Indie Pop Track On Again Exploring Love and Second Chances
  • PEGGY Explores Friendship and Romance in New Single FRIENDS TO LOVERS
  • Michelle Núñez Debuts Cinematic Ballad making the most of it — A Raw, Emotional Reflection on Loss
  • June Releases “Supernova,” a Cosmic Pop Love Song for Dreamers
  • Ella Vaillancourt Drops New Single “One In Million”
  • Lovina Falls Returns with New Single “Light and Low”
  • Estella Dawn Drops a New Cover: “Somebody Else”
  • Charlie McDonald Shares New Single “Time” Inspired by Loss and Memory
  • Natalie Shay Releases New Song “problems.”
  • Carson Cruz Drops “Party Cruise” — A Summer Anthem You’ll Have on Repeat
  • Eva James Releases “The One You Lose,” a Dark Pop Reflection on Distance and Change
  • Marry Cherry Drops Hypnotic Double Single “Satisfaction” and “Crazy Town”
  • Who Cares?” by CATBEAR Nails the Bedroom Pop Formula
  • Terra Renae Debuts “Ignite Me” Ahead of European Tour with Macy Gray
  • Estella Dawn Reinvents Amy Winehouse’s “Back to Black”
  • Jen Ash Lets Go and Leans In with New Single “I Surrender”
  • Carbon City Lights Delivers a Reflective New Track with “Sky Blue”
  • Ian Kaine MacGregor & The Trouble Dolls Debut with “Story of My Life”
  • Lauren Presley Releases New Track “Ghost” from Debut EP
  • Estella Dawn Delivers a Striking Take on Chris Isaak’s “Wicked Game”
  • Tori Lange Follows Up Debut with Bold New Single Meant to Last
  • ZØYA drops double single exploring betrayal and emotional fallout
  • Nuala releases new single Power
  • Carson Cruz Tugs at Heartstrings with Power-Pop Anthem “Be Your Destiny”
  • Vultures of Culture Soar with New Track “Catch and Release”
  • Grace Winslow Drops New Track “I Hope You’re Happy” – A Bitter Anthem for the Burned
  • Jadelyn Drops New Single ‘Throw It Back’ – A Nostalgic Reflection on Youth and Lost Connections
  • Follow

    Home

         

    About

         

    Contact

         

    Daily Readership

    Copyright 2025 Kings of A&R     Website Design by PaleBird